options
Option 1 - Hotel New York Hilton Midtown (https://secure3.hilton.com/en_US/hi/reservation/book.htm?execution=e2s1)
Option 2 - Amazing 2 bedroom apartment near times square (http://au.travelmob.com/holiday-rentals/united-states/new-york/tm-pkkCHrlgbJa)
Comparison of option 1 and 2
Final decision
My final decision is the 2 bedroom apartment near times square (option 2). Based on the pictures, it is a cozy apartment that comfortably sleeps 4 adults with a close distance to attractions and bus terminals which is helpful on the holiday. It is much cheaper than a hotel and in New York City, money is important as everything is expensive. In total it saves more than $600 and on a holiday in America, that money really counts. The apartment contains everything needed for a comfortable living space for 8 days including WiFi, a television, full kitchen appliances etc. Cancellation rules are a downside however there are disadvantages regardless of which place and the lack of reviews are worrying but contacting the person renting is always possible.